Seriously, who likes Appledusk? I think that Mapleshade shouldn’t have been exiled, because there are so many she-cats that weren’t exiled for forbidden romance (Leafpool, Squirrelwhisker, Bluestar to name a few) she’s totally evil, I love her for that but I hate Frecklewish so much. I hate how she only paid attention to Mapleshade when she thought her brother was her mate.