I suggest borrowing a few features from real life microchips to make Nimbatus logic smaller and more straightforward. Take it from the people who have to build it in real life, they know how to keep things simple.
Output Enable - Nearly every real chip and sensor more complex than a NAND gate has at least one "OE" pin. Why? It's so convenient! Imagine two proximity sensors on the same key, how to choose which one gets listened to? In Nimbatus that needs three gates - two AND gates plus an inverter. With real devices, you'd just turn one sensor off.
Inverted Outputs - I'm not the first to ask for this and I know why -- half my logic is inverters! There's no logic simplification for A&!B. I always wish I had inverted outputs for:
Proximity sensors
Direction indicators
Toggle switches
Speedometers
Altitude Indicators
Impulse Drivers
Fuel Tanks
Actually -- anything and everything with outputs, no exceptions
Complementary Outputs - Just an 'invert this output' checkbox isn't enough. All too often we need both outputs simultaneously. You see this all the time in real microchips. Look up "flip flop".
Inverted Inputs - Given complementary outputs, there's extremely few places inverted inputs are still be needed, but the adjustable-strength engine is one. I can never get that thing working quite right. I'd ask for separate invert/not invert checkboxes for the throttle up and throttle down options. Either that, or more consistent behavior when both inputs are activated. Heck, how about both?
And now, a few basic parts I'd suggest adding. I want to keep them simple. I don't want to replace all the stuff people are building, just let them build things with fewer parts and especially, build things they couldn't before.
Monostable Multivibrator - A "triggered impulse driver' which delivers only one pulse per activation.
Jumper/Bus - A buffer that drives many output keys together. What for? "When you see the whites of the enemy's eyes, FIRE ALL ENGINES!"
R/S Flip Flip - Similar to the on/off switch, with complementary outputs and more consistent behavior. It's the one and only piece of logic needed for a basic 2-engine, 2-sensor wall follower!
And now, more esoteric things I know won't make it in the game but I'm hopeful for anyway because they're impractical to build right now:
Priority Encoder - Suppose you have two sets of input, a direction indicator A B for 'move towards enemy' and a pair of proximity indicators C D for 'goodness the edge of the ring looks rather close'. They control the same steering engines D E. You can't use output enable for this, because you can't ignore the edge sensor when the bell tolls for thee. The logic is something awkward like E=((A|B)&A)|(!(A|B)&C), F=((A|B)&B)|(!(A|B)&D), 9 gates, 7-8 if you cheat. Even if it was a 2x3 part I'd save space.
Binary Counter - Toggle-switches aren't good enough, a counter made from those causes glitches. A real, synchronous, one-part counter of just 2 or 3 bits would save a lot of hair-pull.
Binary 1-of-4 Decoder - To use with the binary counter. It'd replace the "stop lights" I build from delay lines and xor gates. What for? Imagine this sequence:
Charge pulse engine attached to dynamite.
Decouple dynamite.
Fire pulse engine.
Detonate.
Master-Slave Flip Flop - Kind of like a switch which can only change the instant its 'enable' input is activated. The thorniest glitches sometimes require these to solve them. They're a basic part in digital electronics, but want a ridiculous number of gates to make - at least nine per bit. Nine. Not to mention how slow they'd be built from basic parts, they'd take a handful of game ticks to respond.
Post
corona_wind
I suggest borrowing a few features from real life microchips to make Nimbatus logic smaller and more straightforward. Take it from the people who have to build it in real life, they know how to keep things simple.
And now, a few basic parts I'd suggest adding. I want to keep them simple. I don't want to replace all the stuff people are building, just let them build things with fewer parts and especially, build things they couldn't before.
And now, more esoteric things I know won't make it in the game but I'm hopeful for anyway because they're impractical to build right now:
Link to comment
Share on other sites
7 replies to this post
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now